Just when we thought we'd escaped "A" — aka Charlotte DiLaurentis — on Pretty Little Liars, things have taken a turn for the very worst. Ever since we've jumped five years into the future, it seems like the torturous villain is more present than ever. Of course, seeing as Charlotte has been killed by another mystery murderer, we've been scrambling to figure out the identity of this new big bad, this "Uber A," if you will. Now, we're turning to you for help: who's the new villain? Examine our full list of suspects, then cast your votes. Vote "up" if you think a character is guilty, and "down" if you think they're innocent. Vote as many times as you want! Voting has ended.
Total Votes Cast: 14,197
Spencer Hastings
POPSUGAR Score: 654
Alison DiLaurentis
POPSUGAR Score: 921
Ezra Fitz
POPSUGAR Score: 616
Mona Vanderwaal
POPSUGAR Score: 809
Caleb Rivers
POPSUGAR Score: 429
Aria Montgomery
POPSUGAR Score: 424
Lucas Gottesman
POPSUGAR Score: 775
Sara Harvey
POPSUGAR Score: 839
Toby Cavanaugh
POPSUGAR Score: 249
Hanna Marin
POPSUGAR Score: 171
Emily Fields
POPSUGAR Score: 77
