I Put Lady Gaga's Liquid Eyeliner to the Test, and Its Smudge-Proof Formula Must Be Magic

POPSUGAR Photography | Macy Cate Williams
POPSUGAR Photography | Macy Cate Williams
While each product featured is independently selected by our editors, we may include paid promotion. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here.

I totally freaked when I discovered that Haus Laboratories, Lady Gaga's beauty brand, offers a liquid eyeliner pen. Gaga is known for her killer graphic liner looks, so I know she takes liner as seriously as I do. Obviously I had to see if it stands up to my favorite formulas.

I ordered Haus Laboratories by Lady Gaga Liquid Eye-Lie-Ner ($20) in Matte Black off of Amazon, and it arrived in a sleek silver and black box. So what's the verdict? This is my new favorite liquid eyeliner pen. I am so impressed by this formula, and I have tried at least 50 different brands. For more photos of my application and of the pen itself, keep reading. Then, get yourself this pen before I take all the stock for myself.

★★★★★

A Close-Up Look
POPSUGAR Photography | Macy Cate Williams

A Close-Up Look

I was able to create a fine point with my cat eye, but the pen could easily allow me to go thicker or thinner if I wish. It dries pretty quickly so you don't have to worry about making a mess.

Felt-Tip Pen Applicator

Here's a better look at the felt tip. The pen itself is very lightweight, so it's easy to maneuver.

The Smudge Test: Before and After
POPSUGAR Photography | Macy Cate Williams

The Smudge Test: Before and After

As previously mentioned, I applied a line, then rubbed it (pretty hard!) for a few seconds. Do you even see a difference? I don't. It remained perfect in color and sharpness.

Sleek and Modern Packaging

The pen comes in both matte and demi-matte finishes.

How It Looks on Lady Gaga

The queen herself rocking a dramatic cat eye.

The Finished Product on Me
POPSUGAR Photography | Macy Cate Williams

The Finished Product on Me

How the eyeliner looks on me, unfiltered in natural sunlight. I can't wait to use it again tomorrow, and the day after that . . .