22 Cute and Creepy Gifts For American Horror Story Fans

By Maggie Panos
While each product featured is independently selected by our editors, we may include paid promotion. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here.

Hoping to get something special for the American Horror Story fan in your life? We have plenty of suggestions! After all, why wait until the holiday season when you can get your pal a Room 64 key now? Apparel and twisted books aren't the only options; there are tons of unexpected gifts like stylish gothic jewelry and snarky t-shirts. Plus, who wouldn't want a Countess figurine for their desk?

The Butchery on Main T-shirt ($20)

Victoria's Glad-Rocks Ring ($37)

"I am the Supreme" Bracelet ($16)

American Horror Story: Hotel DVD ($15)

Freak Show DVD ($13)

Hypodermic Sally Doll ($34)

Gold Skull Earrings ($42)

Victorian Gothic Earrings ($22)

American Horror Story: Asylum on DVD ($14)

Hotel Cortez Room 64 Keychain ($12)

American Horror Story: Coven on DVD ($14)

The Countess Pop! Doll ($17)

I'm the Next Supreme Sweatshirt ($21)

Asylum Wooden Wall Hanger ($15)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black T-Shirt ($20)

Cult-inspired soap ($7)

"Balenciaga" Hoop Wall Hanging ($42)

American Horror Story: Season 1 on DVD ($10)

Roanoke Speak Pig T-Shirt ($10)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black Mug ($10)

Roanoke The Blood Moon Is Coming Necklace ($10)

The World Is Wrong Beanie ($12)