This Oversize Button-Down Is Coastal-Grandmother Chic — and $25 at Target

POPSUGAR Photography | Annalise Mantz
POPSUGAR Photography | Annalise Mantz
While each product featured is independently selected by our editors, we may include paid promotion. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here.

Forget dressing for the job you want — lately, I'm dressing for the lifestyle I want. If wearing the coastal-grandmother aesthetic will help me manifest a future beach house with a garden where I can grow fresh herbs and vegetables for summer pastas, sign me up. Not to mention, this style is timeless, chic, and comfortable — cozy sweaters, printed sundresses, and flowy pants are all definitely my vibe.

So when I spotted the A New Day Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt ($25) on Target's website, I knew I had to give it a try. The oversize, slouchy fit is perfect for pairing with jeans or wearing layered over a frilly tank top. Plus, the cut is incredibly flattering: the first time I slipped on this shirt, my husband told me I looked like I should be sitting on an adirondack chair in Maine, painting a scene from the garden. (You have to love the specificity.) Keep reading for my honest review of this $25 find from Target.

What I Like About the A New Day Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

From the classic cut to the oversize pocket, this shirt is incredibly versatile. The first time I wore it, I styled it simply with jeans and Chelsea boots. Another day, I layered it over a graphic tee and miniskirt. You could also wear it under a blazer or sweater vest for a workwear look. Since I ordered the shirt in pure white, I know I'll be able to wear it with a variety of outfits for years to come.

What's Worth Noting About the A New Day Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

The fit of this shirt is definitely oversize. If you order it in your typical size, expect a loose, blousy fit — ideal for the coastal-grandmother aesthetic. If you prefer a more tailored fit, size down.

This shirt is 98 percent cotton and two percent spandex and does wrinkle easily. I found that a quick steam loosened up any creases or wrinkles out of the wash, but some did creep back into the fabric throughout the day. Is it the highest-quality button-down shirt I've ever worn? No — but it is a great value for the $25 price tag.

POPSUGAR Photography | Annalise Mantz

Who the A New Day Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt Is Best For

The blousy, oversize fit of this button-down would work well for anyone who wants to try the coastal-grandmother style — or just prefers shirts with a looser fit. Both the white and blue striped options look timelessly chic with everything from skirts to trousers to denim.

Additional Details

  • This shirt comes in sizes XS-XXL.
  • The shirt is available in a blue and white striped pattern. Target also makes this shirt in solid black or cream stripes, but both colors are currently out of stock.

Rating: ★★★★☆