This Copycat Recipe For Disney's PB&J Milkshake Has a Boozy Twist: Peanut Butter Whiskey!

Updated on July 3, 2020 at 5:00 PM

POPSUGAR Photography | Megan duBois

One of our favorite frozen treats to get while walking around Disney's Hollywood Studios is the peanut butter and jelly milkshake. The frozen concoction, which can be found at 50's Prime Time Cafe, tastes like childhood in a cup and is the perfect thing to cool you off on a hot Florida day. But since it'll probably be a while before we're back at Disney, this drink is (thankfully) an easy one to whip up at home. And because we love making just about any frozen drink into a cocktail, we gave this one an adult spin by adding peanut butter whiskey!

Just like the official recipe from Disney, our copycat version of the peanut butter and jelly milkshake has vanilla ice cream, creamy peanut butter, jelly, and milk. But the addition of Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey just takes it to a whole new level of delicious. The drink takes just a few minutes to prep and make, and even though it's boozy, the delicious taste of peanut butter and jelly will make you feel like a kid again.

Boozy Disney Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake

Prep Time3 minutes

Yield1 serving

Original Recipe by Megan DuBois

INGREDIENTS

1 tablespoon creamy peanut butter
2 tablespoons jelly (strawberry or grape)
2 cups vanilla ice cream
1/4 cup milk
1 shot peanut butter whiskey (Skrewball or any other kind you like)

INSTRUCTIONS

Add all ingredients to the carafe of a blender, and blend until smooth.
Add additional whiskey, peanut butter, or jelly to taste.
Pour into a glass, and enjoy!

Notes

You can use either grape or strawberry jelly for this milkshake. I used strawberry, but go with your childhood favorite!

This Copycat Recipe For Disney's PB&J Milkshake Has a Boozy Twist: Peanut Butter Whiskey!

Boozy Disney Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake

INGREDIENTS

INSTRUCTIONS

Notes

For the Love of Tinned Fish and Chicken Fat: Meet the TikTok Generation's Julia Child

To find some quick dirt on someone, Reddit is an obvious first stop.

The Life of a Private Chef to Pro Athletes

You've seen the viral TikToks: a private chef invites you into an Architectural Digest-worthy kitchen, where you can watch as they cook elaborate breakfasts, lunches, and dinners for a rich and famous client.

15 Top-Rated Amazon Knives to Sharpen Your Cooking Skills

Whether you fancy yourself the next Ina Garten or are just happy with yourself for not burning that grilled cheese sandwich, investing in quality cooking gadgets, like cookware sets or air fryers, can change everything.

20 Editor-Approved Kitchen Products That'll Help You Elevate Your Cooking

There's an easy way to get excited about stepping up your game in the kitchen, and it's not finding a new viral recipe: it's buying yourself some new supplies.

13 Top-Rated Amazon Cookware Sets, Including Editor Favorites

Let's be honest, spending more than $100 on a single pot or pan can make accumulating a solid cookware set seem financially unfeasible for some.

Meghan Markle's Le Creuset Cooking Set Is Going Viral, and It's 30% Off Right Now

Le Creuset products are legendary among home cooks and chefs alike, and most recently, they're the topic of conversation as Meghan Markle reaches for her Le Creuset set over and over again on her Netflix show "With Love, Meghan."

4 Editors Put Taylor Swift's Favorite Candy to the Test

The internet loves to joke about social media algorithms knowing you better than you know yourself.

Important: the Answer to What Harrison Ford Was Eating in That SAG Awards Moment

"Los Angeles is known as the city of dreams.

Your Sushi May Need a Makeover

So long, umami and omakase — it's time to make room for a new sushi buzzword destined for the margins of Japanese-American menus.

Did We Kill the Martini?

I'll admit I don't drink alcohol very often.

True Life: I'm a "Menu Sleuth"

"How do you always know what to order?" my boyfriend asks me every time we're out to eat together.

The Best Meal-Delivery Kits and Subscriptions of 2025

As much as we love a home-cooked meal, making dishes from scratch can be a time-consuming endeavor.

The Best Super Bowl Appetizers For Your Party of 2

Presenting a Nacho Cheese Sauce You'll Want to Pour on Everything

We don't always make nacho cheese from scratch, but when we do, we use this trusted Guy Fieri recipe.

The 18 Best Chicken Wing Recipes For Your Super Bowl Spread

Just like the halftime show and cheerleaders, wings are considered to be a great component on any game day, but who says they can't be the main event?

I Doubted the Mushroom Coffee Hype, but This Superblend Proved Me Wrong

I'm not huge on bandwagon trends: I never watch movies when they first come out, I still don't own Crocs, I've never tried the Keto diet, and I tend to wait a while before trying a new product.

The Best Nonalcoholic Drinks to Sip on Through Dry January and Beyond

Whether you're sober, sober curious, partaking in Damp January or Dry January, or simply want to curb your alcohol intake, there are a handful of delicious drinks you can sip on — all of which don't have a drop of alcohol in them.

46 New Year's Eve Appetizers to Ring In 2025

Gone are the days of wild, all-nighter New Year's Eve parties.